This winter was a little quieter than usual for the folks at Silver Creek Specialty Meats in Oshkosh, Wisconsin. For generations, winter was when hunters would make regular visits to the low-rise white brick facility near the shore of Lake Winnebago, carrying the odds and ends of the deer they had killed the previous fall so it could be turned into venison sausages. This year, though, no hunters came.
“It’s not quite black and white. What do we do in the meantime?”
In August, Silver Creek Specialty Meats sent out a letter notifying customers that it would no longer accept venison for processing. “As you are probably aware,” the letter said, “chronic wasting disease in the wild deer population of the State of Wisconsin has been steadily spreading. The disease has now been found in wild deer in 19 counties throughout the state. Due to the spread of the disease it has become extremely difficult to screen out any venison coming from CWD infected areas.”
Deer with chronic wasting disease, or CWD, tremble and drool. They often cannot hold their heads up. Eventually, they lose so much weight that they are little more than hide and bone. The disease arises from a particular prion — single-protein infectious agents linked to various neurodegenerative diseases in mammals. And prion diseases are always fatal.
Even though chronic wasting disease hasn’t been shown to be a risk to human health, its similarity to other prion diseases that are — including “mad cow disease” and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, which has symptoms resembling Alzheimer’s disease — has been cause for concern for years. News last summer about an ongoing Canadian study in which two macaque monkeys contracted the disease after eating meat from a CWD-infected deer — the first time an animal so closely related to humans developed CWD — only exacerbated the worries.
“That sealed the deal for us,” says Katy Lehman, Silver Creek Specialty Meats’ president of operations. The letter went out soon afterward.
And yet, a short drive from Wisconsin’s CWD hotspot, another venison sausage processor continues — as do dozens of commercial venison processers in the state — to make venison sausage from the meat brought in by hunters. The butcher, who asked that his name and the name of his shop not be used for fear of losing business, rankles at Silver Creek Specialty Meats’ decision to stop processing wild deer meat, because it creates unnecessary fear and worry.
The media sensationalizes the disease, he says, “every time there’s a scare with a monkey.”
The owner says that out of an abundance of caution, he and his employees follow careful procedures, including butchering the venison in a separate location reserved only for deer meat, and that employees don’t touch the deer’s brain or spinal column. This is more than enough to ensure safety, he suggested — not least because there is no evidence that chronic wasting disease is a threat to humans.
It’s a near perfect encapsulation of the chronic wasting disease conundrum: Two meat processing companies, less than 100 miles apart, that only want the best for their customers — and each animated by a very different assessment of the risk posed by CWD.
Both say that science is the basis for their conclusion. And both are correct.
To date, CWD has been detected in captive and free-ranging deer, elk, and moose in at least 24 states and two Canadian provinces, but it is not exactly a new disease. CWD was first discovered in captive mule deer at the Colorado Division of Wildlife Foothills Wildlife Research Facility in 1967, but it would be years before it was understood to be what’s now called a transmissible spongiform encephalopathy, or TSE. At the time, these diseases, which turn brains spongy, were a mystery, and only three were known: scrapie, a disease of sheep, known for over 250 years; Creutzfeldt-Jakob, a disease of humans; and kuru, also a disease of humans, that was only found among the natives of Papua New Guinea who ritually ate human brains.
Scientists had already discovered that the infectious agent behind TSEs could not be killed by boiling or exposure to acids, radiation, or antibiotics. But it wasn’t until 1982 that Stanley Prusiner, an American medical researcher, discovered the prion, and pegged it as the cause of TSEs. (He later won the Nobel Prize for his work.)
Then came mad cow. Properly called bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), it was identified in the United Kingdom in 1986. The British government initially claimed that beef from mad cow-infected cattle was safe to eat, but more than 200 people across Europe would later die from it. The first case of BSE in humans, known as variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, was diagnosed in 1996. That 10-year gap between discovery of a disease in cows, and the recognition, despite all assurances to the contrary, that it was a threat to people who ate contaminated meat, is the cause of nearly all the worry about chronic wasting disease today.
While nobody knows exactly how CWD is transmitted from deer to deer, saliva is highly suspect. Nose mucus, urine, and feces are also possibilities. However, its leaps across the country and the world are best explained by live animals transported as part of the captive deer and elk industry. While typically called “deer farms,” in the United States, these businesses are predominantly captive hunt facilities and their suppliers. Farm-raised venison is mostly imported from New Zealand, which is CWD-free. Hunters dumping carcasses or parts in places far away from the kill site may also contribute to CWD’s spread, experts say.
The most recent scare with monkeys started last year. Stefanie Czub, a prion researcher based in Alberta, Canada and head of a reference lab for mad cow disease for the Canadian Food Inspection Agency and the World Organization for Animal Health, flew 2,000 miles to Ottawa, Canada’s capital, to deliver the results of her monkey research to representatives of various federal agencies in person. It was that important.
Her news was that five cynomolgus macaque monkeys had contracted CWD in a years-long study where 18 macaques had been infected with CWD through various means. The results from three of the macaques would have been news enough: Two had contracted CWD after its prions had been applied directly to their brains. This was new. And another macaque in Czub’s study had contracted CWD after eating brain tissue from an infected white-tailed deer.
The World Health Organization, the CDC, Health Canada, and numerous American states all recommend that no one eat the meat of any prion-infected deer.
“The two remaining animals may be, from a human health point of view, the most important ones,” says Czub. They were fed meat from CWD-infected white-tailed deer that didn’t look sick. These were the kind of deer that any hunter might eat without a second thought. But 5.4 and 6.2 years after first being fed this deer meat, the macaques, previously thought to be immune, showed subtle symptoms. They were killed and CWD prions were found in their spinal cords.
The results were a surprise, given that an earlier study had found that this species of macaque appeared immune to chronic wasting disease. After flying to Ottawa, Czub presented the findings at the Prion 2017 conference in Edinburgh, Scotland last May. Over the summer, more than 1,000 people, mostly veterinarians from federal agencies, dialed into a webinar organized by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Czub says. She and her fellow investigators still haven’t written a scientific paper, and while Czub says she intends to write up these intermediary findings, the study is only at its halfway point. Ten of the original 21 animals (three are controls) are still alive.
Czub would like to keep the remaining macaques alive as long as possible. She wants the disease to have the chance to develop, since prion diseases are known to take years to show symptoms. That might also give her a better idea of what the disease might look like in humans.
And yet, that kind of research is expensive — $7.9 million Canadian, so far, she says — and she’s currently in the process of securing funding for another two years. Meanwhile, the macaques are housed in Germany, in one of the few facilities in the world certified to work with both primates and prions. Because of the difficulty of working with primates and prions, Czub says, “This experiment is never going to be repeated.”
The World Health Organization, the CDC, Health Canada, and the departments of health and natural resources in Wisconsin and other states including Minnesota, Colorado, Mississippi, Illinois, North Dakota, and South Dakota aren’t waiting for more studies: All recommend that no one eat the meat of any prion-infected deer.
Some hunters feel these recommendations don’t go far enough. “This is one of the most outrageous human susceptibility experiments in history,” says Dave Clausen, a retired veterinarian, former chairman of the Wisconsin Natural Resources Board, and avid deer hunter.
Other hunters defy the recommendations — and sometimes that defiance has a scientific basis. “I harvested an elk several years ago, and the adult turned out to be positive for chronic wasting disease,” Walt Cook, a clinical associate professor at Texas A&M University’s College of Veterinary Medicine, said at a Texas Parks and Wildlife Commission hearing. “Well, I ate it. That was my choice; and I don’t think I look like I’m wasting away, do I?”
Later, Cook admitted that he would not let his wife or daughter eat meat from CWD-positive animals, and explained that he had worked with deer and elk in a CWD-infected area of Wyoming for 23 years. The infected elk he knowingly ate, he said, was unlikely his first CWD exposure, and he’s confident of his chances. CWD most resembles scrapie of sheep, Cook says. “This disease [scrapie] has been around for hundreds, possibly thousands of years. Literally millions of people have been exposed to scrapie with no evidence of transmission.” He also points to research that shows that CWD prions are simply the wrong shape to interact with human prions.
Timothy Kurt did that research at the University of California, San Diego. Kurt looked at the role played by the 210 amino acids in the prion protein to figure out why CWD is transmitted to some species and not others. He found that when a species had a different amino acid in a key location, the diseased prion wouldn’t fit neatly into the healthy prion, like a zipper with teeth that don’t fit together. This, Kurt believes, is CWD’s species barrier. The amino acid sequence differed between humans and deer at a key location. A different study showed that a macaque’s amino acids matched the deer sequence in the same spot, but not the human one.
It’s evidence like this that prompts James Kroll, also known as “Dr. Deer” on the television show “North American Whitetail,” to dismiss concerns over chronic wasting disease as absurd. Kroll said he does not normally test deer where he hunts. “And why would I want to?” he asked. “I am not concerned about eating ‘infected deer!’” He adds that he’s proud of the special report his program did on chronic wasting disease, in which his colleague ate CWD-infected meat on camera.
Kroll has never studied CWD in the lab or in the field, but what he says counts more with hunters, especially in Wisconsin, and not only because he’s on TV. In 2011, he was selected as a deer trustee by Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker to straighten out the mess CWD had made of that state’s deer herd. Kroll believes that CWD is widespread, “has been out there for a long, long time,” and that what appears to be an uptick in cases of CWD are simply an artifact of looking for it. “If you test for it, you’ll find it,” he says.
This, of course, ignores the opinions of his colleagues who study CWD, and states like New Jersey, Oregon, Maine, and California, which have tested extensively for chronic wasting disease for years, and have never had a positive result. It also ignores the states, such as Illinois and New York, where CWD has only been found in a small area although deer throughout the state have been tested. And while Kroll argues that “CWD has been a great cash cow for a lot of states and scientists,” federal funding for CWD research and monitoring was actually cut back in 2012.
In November, two Wisconsin congressmen introduced a bill to restore federal funding for chronic wasting disease surveillance and research. A similar bill was introduced by Senator Jon Tester, a Democrat representing Montana. The bills are still in committee.
“Following basic, required protocols of separating venison from other meat, and removing the central nervous system and disposing of it properly, are the primary way of addressing processing concerns,” says Jeff Sindelar, an associate professor of meat science at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
“There has never been a link between eating venison and CWD,” he says. “The risk is not zero, but it’s pretty close to zero.”
When consumers are worried about the risk of CWD, he says, these are socially-based concerns, not concerns based on science. “There has never been a link between eating venison and CWD,” he says. “The risk is not zero, but it’s pretty close to zero.”
Whether “pretty close to zero” is a comfort or concern is a matter of perspective, of course, and when asked, Sindelar said that he doesn’t make any recommendations to processors about removing a deer’s lymph nodes, even though those are what Wisconsin’s Department of Natural Resources, and others around the country, test to diagnose the disease.
“There are lymph nodes throughout the body,” Sindelar says. “It would be unreasonable to remove them all.”
As it stands, hunters in Wisconsin are not required to have their deer tested for chronic wasting disease, but many still do. (CWD tests are mandatory for all hunter-killed deer in some areas of Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Texas, Virginia, and Alberta, Canada. All 50 states do some kind of CWD testing on wild deer, either random, voluntary, or of sick deer.) In Wisconsin, if a kill tests positive, hunters can expect a phone call from state wildlife officials. If those hunters, like Kroll, say they plan to eat the meat anyway or share it with others, they’ll be asked to provide a list of names so the state’s Department of Health Services can confirm who consumed it and add those individuals to the department’s long-term disease surveillance program.
That’s when some hunters simply hang up, says Jim Kazmierczak, the public health veterinarian for the State of Wisconsin. Some say they don’t trust the government, Kazmierczak says. Some have other reasons not to participate. But many say yes, and so far about 1,000 people in Wisconsin are helping the state learn more about any potential human health risk posed by chronic wasting disease.
Joni Scheftel, the state public health veterinarian next door in Minnesota, says that any hunter who said he or she was going to eat venison from a CWD-infected deer in her state would get a phone call directly from her. “I would be showing up at their house if they didn’t want to talk to me by phone,” Scheftel says. “There is no evidence at this point that CWD has ever been transmitted to a person, but we still feel very strongly that people should not eat meat from any prion-infected animal.”
That surely sounds overwrought to some hunters who believe that, with millions of people eating venison each year, a human infection would have shown itself in the 50 years since CWD was first discovered. Or, that the CDC or other health researchers, ever on the lookout, would have pegged a human prion disease cluster to CWD, if it were indeed the cause.
But sentiments like Scheftel’s are enough for the team back at Silver Creek Specialty Meats in Oshkosh. “Consumer safety is our number one concern,” the company’s August letter stated, “and no matter how small the risk (if any) of humans being infected by the disease we are not, and never will be, willing to put profit before the safety and well-being of our customers.”
Still, Katy Lehman allows that Silver Creek’s decision is not necessarily the right one for everyone. “It’s not quite black and white,” she says. Silver Creek considered the size of its processing facility, its location and their product mix in its decision, Lehman notes, and those factors may add up differently for other companies. With no answer yet on whether or not CWD is a human health risk, Lehman says, the only question can be, “What do we do in the meantime?”
Madeline Bodin is a Vermont-based freelance writer specializing in wildlife conservation science. Her work has appeared in Scientific American, Popular Mechanics, National Wildlife, and many other publications.