For Afghan Health Workers, a Gauntlet of Making Do

Republish

On a Sunday in early June, the first battered Afghan Border Police pickups roared into a district hospital parking lot at 8:30 a.m. The small, four-building medical facility sits on the edge of Spin Boldak, a busy frontier town in eastern Kandahar straddling the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan. It was the height of the summer fighting season, and the police convoy had come under Taliban attack while on a routine border patrol. As the vehicles rolled to a halt in the small hospital parking lot, stunned soldiers emerged from a cloud of dust and exhaust fumes, while others were hustled onto gurneys by the clinic’s small staff.

Inside the hospital, Dr. Zamaryalai Ghafori, 34, moved calmly among the patients, helping to bandage a shrapnel wound on an officer before moving swiftly to dress the bleeding head of a young boy involved in a motorcycle crash. For all his calm, Ghafori and his small team toil daily against absurdly high odds. Long hours and low pay had recently driven another surgeon at the hospital to quit — a common occurrence. This has left Ghafori in the middle of a 72-hour shift and, on this morning, the only surgeon available at a hospital that — like so many in Afghanistan — faces chronic shortfalls of personnel, beds, and even standard medical equipment.

“Sometimes we don’t have [clean] water in [the operating theater] for hand washing,” Ghafori told me. “This is very important. Because there is no water, we are buying from outside water and bringing it to the hospital.”

Dr. Ghafori gives nurse Khalid Ahmad instructions before reseting a broken arm. With no functioning air conditioning, temperatures in the operating theater routinely climb to stifling levels.

That sort of do-it-yourself resolve is testament not just to the tenacity of many Afghan doctors and nurses, but to the country’s status among the least medically equipped in the world. And while health care access and quality has been steadily improving over the last two decades, challenges abound. In a country of more than 37 million, Afghanistan has just 150 hospitals, including regional, district, and special military hospitals, and a mere three doctors per 10,000 people — a fraction of the nearly 26 doctors per 10,000 people in the United States. As of 2015, the country had just five hospital beds per 10,000 people, compared to approximately 30 hospital beds per 10,000 people in the U.S. in 2013 and 134 per 10,000 in Japan in 2012.

The health care shortfalls are particularly pronounced in rural areas, where 85 percent of the population lives below the poverty line and infection and malnutrition are widespread. Large, remote districts, sometimes encompassing hundreds of square kilometers and hosting dozens of villages, may be serviced by a single small community clinic staffed by one or two nurses. Many such facilities might carry a basic stock of medicines and supplies, but they remain ill-equipped to deal with even common issues like complications from childbirth, or accidents involving serious bodily trauma.

Meanwhile, the threat of violence hangs heavy over medical personnel. In many instances, doctors and other health workers face direct physical threats, particularly when they are known to have treated government or military personnel — unavoidable in many areas. In the first six months of this year, the World Health Organization tallied 58 attacks on health care facilities. More than a dozen health care workers and patients were killed over the same period, and 25 others were injured.

“Just four kilometers far from our hospital, the area is under control of Taliban,” Ghafori says, explaining that three or four times a week, Taliban and Afghan forces clash in these areas. He says sometimes, when the police bring their injured soldiers, they put their guns to hospital workers’ heads, warning, “If anyone died, we’ll kill you.”

Doctors at the Spin Boldak District Hospital race to treat a police officer injured by shrapnel from a Taliban-laid roadside bomb. Such threats are ever-present.
A young man waits to go into surgery at the Spin Boldak District Hospital in eastern Kandahar Province.
A local man collects medication from the hospital’s internal pharmacy. Basic medications are often in short supply.

The equipment shortages and physical threats take their toll, and the country’s health care woes are compounded by the steady loss of expertise as experienced surgeons — who earn on average between $200 and $250 per month — move overseas in search of personal safety and a living wage.

Those who remain in Afghanistan learn quickly to make do in difficult circumstances. At Spin Boldak, the day’s injuries threatened to quickly overwhelm the district hospital’s resources, and the chief health officer, Jawid Afghan, worried aloud about the possible fallout. “You have seen today,” he told me. “I don’t think that they will have enough cannula; I don’t think that they will have enough [IV fluid].”

His list went on.

Some doctors and nurses, like Ghafori and his team, obtain much-needed supplies and medications using their own funds. Other medical personnel become de facto engineers, repairing vital solar power systems, fixing plumbing, and performing a wide range of tasks far outside their ostensible job descriptions. And the prohibitively high cost of certain orthopedic surgical equipment like bone saws and drills — desperately needed given the injuries many hospitals see in this perennially war-torn nation — leave them in particularly short supply.

In Kabul’s Wazir Akbar Khan Hospital, doctors recently dealt with a lack of orthopedic drills by purchasing electric carpentry drills to use instead. Patients there, as in many places, are also asked to bring their own syringes if coming for injections, in case of shortage.

Dr. Gul Ahmad Ayubi, director of the Wazir Akbar Khan facility, chuckled ruefully when asked if his hospital receives enough funding from the Afghan government. “No,” he said “because the budget of the Ministry of Public Health is very low.”

“Experienced staff we have,” he added, “but unfortunately we don’t have equipment.”

 


 

A Precious Ounce of Prevention

Scenes from two health clinics in Badakhshan Province, in northern Afghanistan, spring 2019.

A young female patient is consoled by a relative as she awaits treatment. She was carried to the clinic by family after collapsing from malnutrition and dehydration.
Nurses quickly administered an intravenous drip. Malnourishment is a chronic problem in the region.
Another patient, this one a young boy, is attended by a clinic staffer as he receives a nutrient injection.
Women waiting to see medical staff are watched over by a facility’s chowkidor – an unarmed guard who also fills a number of non-medical roles around the clinic.
A busy time of day is indicated by the pile of shoes in front of a clinic’s door.
Young mothers wait for their children to be seen by a female nurse.
Vials of ampicillin – a penicillin-type antibiotic – sit on a desk in an examination room. These crucial medications are often in short supply.
So, too, is power. Here, solar power, stored on batteries, provides the only source of electricity to an entire clinic.
Meanwhile, this spare but tidy ambulance is one of the few that services an entire district.

 


 

A Capital of Contrasts and Chaos

Scenes from three Kabul hospitals, in summer and early fall 2019.

Doctors at Kabul’s Wazir Akbar Khan Hospital assist a patient injured in a suicide attack less than a kilometer from the facility.
Blood stains the floor, next to the henna stained feet a morgue worker, as casualties from the early September attack arrive.
Dr. Hares Arif catches his breath between waves of incoming casualties. The blast killed 10, including an American serviceman.
Facilities in the capital can often offer more medical resources — both routine and emergency. Here, prosthetic legs, all made with plastic recycled from old prosthetics, sit in the corner of the exam room at a large orthopedic clinic run by the Red Cross.
And advanced medical care can be obtained at private hospitals — for a steep price. Here, surgeons perform a routine appendectomy at the comparatively well-equipped Blossom Hospital, a private clinic in downtown Kabul.
Here, a mechanical ventilator sits alongside various medical tools, and a doctor’s iPhone, at the Blossom Hospital. Most Afghan citizens will never see a facility like this, however.
Most of the population, including both doctors and patients like this one, waiting to be collected by his family from the Wazir Akbar Khan Hospital in Kabul, must make do with a lower quality of care.
The X-ray room at Wazir Akbar Khan Hospital.
A doctor diagnoses a patient in the hospital’s orthopedic ward.
When specialized surgical tools are not available, doctors must improvise. Here, a surgeon at Wazir Akbar Khan Hospital uses a carpentry drill to preform an ankle fusion procedure. (Image taken December, 2017.)

 


 

All in a Day’s Work

Portraits from Spin Boldak District Hospital, Kandahar Province, southern Afghanistan, August 2019.

Less than 10 percent of the Afghan population lives in Kabul, and the vast majority of people are scattered in rural areas like Spin Boldak. Here, a young boy arrives at the clinic with a severe head injury from a motorcycle crash.
Vehicle accidents form the majority of non-conflict related trauma injuries seen at this hospital.
Many experienced surgeons in Afghanistan — who earn on average between $200 and $250 per month — eventually burn out and move overseas.
Those who remain in Afghanistan learn quickly to make do in difficult circumstances — sometimes buying supplies with their own funds.
Little in the way of a power grid extends to places like Spin Boldak, where this diesel generator is the district hospital’s primary source of electricity.
For Afghan Health Workers, a Gauntlet of Making Do

Here, a former bathroom has been converted to a multi-use storage and equipment cleaning room.

For Afghan Health Workers, a Gauntlet of Making Do

Without a functioning autoclave for sterilizing equipment, doctors soak surgical tools in chlorine.

For Afghan Health Workers, a Gauntlet of Making Do

Trained as a physiotherapist, Abdul Halim inspects the leg of a man injured by a roadside bomb.

For Afghan Health Workers, a Gauntlet of Making Do

Because of chronic understaffing, staff at the hospital must often fill multiple roles at once, including assisting with surgeries.

Dr. Ghafori catches his breath as patients continue to stream into the emergency ward. Sometimes, he says, hospital staff are threatened at gunpoint. “If anyone dies,” they are told, “we’ll kill you.”
In rare quiet moments, doctors and nurses at Spin Boldak use the time to catch up on sleep.

 


 

Kern Hendricks is an independent photographer and journalist. He has been based in Kabul, Afghanistan since 2017. More of his work can be viewed on Instagram @kernhendricks.